Latin America Still Lacks “Social Infrastructure” that Exist in U.S. Tech Hubs
By Josette Rigsby (from SXSW)
The drive to become the next Twitter or Amazon doesn’t stop on the shores of the U.S. Talented Latin Americans are taking advantage of innovations in open source, social media and highly advanced, scalable technology solutions like cloud computing to spawn new ventures beyond being service providers for U.S. firms. While entrepreneurship has gained momentum, there are still significant challenges to explosive growth in Latin American technology sector.
Over the weekend, I stopped in at a session called: “Cashing Out: Start-up Successes in Latin America” featuring entrepreneurs Andes Barreto of Onswipe, Grooveshark, and Socialatom Group, Daniel Undurraga of Latin American Groupon and Esteban Sosnik of Chile based Atakama, and previously of Wanako Games that was acquired by Vivendi/Activision.
All of the entrepreneurs we spoke with agreed that Latin America does not yet have the social infrastructure necessary to consistently support emerging technology firms. Unlike California, Boston, MA, New York and other U.S. start-up hot beds, no well-established networks exist to assist Latin American companies in their embryonic stage. There are no low cost loans or angel networks, few investors that are willing to assume the risk of providing seed money and limited opportunities to collaborate with others about lessons learned.
More Skin in the Game
According to Undurraga, Latin American entrepreneurs must invest significantly more than their American peers. Undurraga said, “Everything is very harder here than in the U.S. There is a huge opportunity to create a venture fund now in Latin America with a Silicon Valley style. The fund should be built with an incubator or some sort of platform for helping entrepreneurs so they can focus on their business model.”
Some organizations like Endeavor exist to support new Latin American firms, but panelist noted that Endeavor and many others target companies after they are well established – not when they are moving from concept to execution.
In addition to the challenges of acquiring funding, panelist noted that cultural factors like aversion to failure and the investor expectations that founder’s personal networks of family and friends contribute financially are also “annoyances” in the Latin American emerging technology market. Although mature support systems don’t currently exist, Sosnik noted that current technology leaders are making themselves available to mentor the next generation of talent. This social reinvestment could create some of the homegrown support networks that are necessary for start-ups to thrive.
Opportunities are Abundant
Starting a new technology company in Latin America is challenging, but there is also significant opportunity. The Latin American markets are not yet saturated with established market leaders, making it easier for new companies to gain customer share. Other developments in the Latin American economy that could spur start-up growth include:
- Wider availability of consumer credit cards has increased the potential customer base for e-commerce transactions
- Exponential growth in mobile device utilization provides opportunities and content types
- Availability of resources trained in large scale implementation due to participation in near shore IT consulting
- Historically lower staff attrition rates due to cultural loyalties to organizations
Cesar D’Onofrio of Argentina, is CEO of Common Sense, agreed that it is challenging to operate in the Latin American market, but his firm is managing to grow 20% per year and augmenting staff to meet demand. He noted that his very presence at SXSW Interactive demonstrated the changing tide of emerging technology in Latin America. D’Onofrio’ said, “My firm is interested in seeing what is coming next so that we can stay on the edge of emerging technology. We want to ensure that we are knowledgeable and able to guide our clients to the best possible solutions.”
All the articles that say Latin America is the next Silicon Valley are wrong. The entrepreneurial spirit and emerging technology are growing and thriving, but the result will not be a U.S. clone, it will be uniquely Latin American. (The annual South by Southwest Interactive conference kicked off in Austin, TX last week and featured an entire track on Latin America for the first time.)
South by Southwest Interactive this year was fantastic because of the focus on Latin America, among other things. Some of the exciting things entrepreneurs from the region are doing were shown to an American audience who didn't realize that technology innovation and technology entrepreneurship could come out of the region. Not only were the perspectives of entrepreneurs such as Eduardo Sosnik, Daniel Undurraga and Andres Barreto invaluable, but also those of Joseph Crump from Razorfish who talked about the new digital middle class, the rising "Classe C" population who are more technologically savvy than the "Classe B & A" and will prove to be a huge new market for U.S. firms. Also, entrepreneurs such as César Salazar who are leading the way with new VC Funds. Salazar just became General Partner at a brand new venture fund with $2 million designated to early stage seed startups in Mexico who will be creating innovative new technology startups. The fund, called Mexican VC (www.mexican.vc) is the first of it's kind, and is headed by David Weekly with Silicon Valley investment dollars.
Finally, the networking that happened was at SXSW was spectacular, with entrepreneurs from Chile, Colombia, Brazil, Argentina, Guatemala, Mexico and the U.S. meeting each other for the first time and planning new cross-border ventures with each other.
There are big plans for next year, and I think the implications for nearshore providers is very interesting. Already we're starting to see a new breed of nearshore provider, such as Koombea, a youthful innovative nearshore provider that provides ruby-on-rails custom development to U.S. ISVs. These kinds of cutting-edge technologies are exploding in the U.S., and nearshore providers should take heed and start exploring these types of technologies, or others such as Titanium, the mobile app development platform by Appcelerator, and go to conferences like SXSW where they can see the huge growth of these technologies.
The lesson of SXSW Interactive then for nearshore providers is: innovate or be irrelevant.
Josette, thanks for mentioning us; we really enjoyed SXSW. Here is our experience http://blog.getcs.com/2011/03/what-i-learnt-sxsw by Nancy Medica. We hope that in 2012 the conference has more LatAm sessions and panels, Common Sense undertakes that responsibility!